Claude-scholar skill-improver
This skill should be used when the user asks to "apply skill improvements", "update skill from plan", "execute improvement plan", "fix skill issues", "implement skill recommendations", or mentions applying improvements from quality review reports. Reads improvement-plan-{name}.md files generated by skill-quality-reviewer and intelligently merges and executes the suggested changes to improve Claude Skills quality.
git clone https://github.com/Galaxy-Dawn/claude-scholar
T=$(mktemp -d) && git clone --depth=1 https://github.com/Galaxy-Dawn/claude-scholar "$T" && mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills && cp -r "$T/skills/skill-improver" ~/.claude/skills/galaxy-dawn-claude-scholar-skill-improver && rm -rf "$T"
skills/skill-improver/SKILL.mdSkill Improver
Execute improvement plans generated by
skill-quality-reviewer to automatically update and fix issues in Claude Skills.
Core Workflow
Read improvement-plan-{name}.md ↓ Parse improvement items (High/Medium/Low priority) ↓ Group changes by file ↓ Detect and resolve conflicts ↓ Backup original files ↓ Execute updates (Edit or Write tools) ↓ Verify results ↓ Generate update-report
When to Use
Trigger phrases:
- "Apply improvements from improvement-plan-git-workflow.md"
- "Update my skill based on the quality report"
- "Execute the improvement plan for api-helper"
- "Fix the issues identified in quality review"
Use this skill when:
- Applying improvements from an improvement plan
- Updating a skill based on quality review feedback
- Executing recommended fixes from
skill-quality-reviewer - Implementing structured improvements to skill documentation
Step-by-Step Guide
Step 1: Load the Improvement Plan
Read the
improvement-plan-{skill-name}.md file generated by skill-quality-reviewer.
# Plan is typically in current directory ls improvement-plan-*.md # Or specify full path read /path/to/improvement-plan-my-skill.md
Validate the plan:
- File exists and is readable
- Contains priority sections (High/Medium/Low)
- Has structured improvement items
- Includes file paths and suggested changes
See
references/plan-format.md for detailed plan structure.
Step 2: Parse and Group Changes
Extract all improvement suggestions and organize by target file.
Extract from each item:
- File path (e.g.,
orSKILL.md:line:line
)references/file.md - Dimension (Description Quality, Content Organization, etc.)
- Impact (+X points)
- Current content
- Suggested content
- Reason for change
Build update queue:
by_file = { "SKILL.md": [change1, change2, ...], "references/guide.md": [change3, ...], "examples/demo.md": [change4, ...], }
Step 3: Detect and Resolve Conflicts
Check for conflicts when multiple changes affect the same content.
Resolution strategy:
- High priority takes precedence over medium/low
- If same priority, preserve first change
- Flag conflicts for manual review
- Document resolution in update report
See
references/merge-strategies.md for detailed merge logic.
Step 4: Sort by Priority
Order changes by priority within each file.
Priority order:
- High Priority (execute first)
- Medium Priority (execute second)
- Low Priority (execute last)
Step 5: Backup and Execute
Backup location:
~/.claude/skills/backup/{skill-name}-{timestamp}/
# Use backup script ~/.claude/skills/skill-improver/scripts/backup-skill.sh <skill-path>
Apply changes:
- Use Edit tool for existing content
- Use Write tool for new files
- Verify each change was applied
Step 6: Verify and Report
Verification checks:
- YAML syntax valid
- All modified files exist and are valid
- New files were created successfully
- No unintended changes occurred
# Use verify script ~/.claude/skills/skill-improver/scripts/verify-update.sh <skill-path>
Generate update-report-{skill-name}-{timestamp}.md documenting:
- Summary (files modified, files created, total changes)
- Changes Applied (per-file breakdown)
- Quality Improvement (before/after scores)
- Verification Results
- Backup Location
See
examples/update-report-example.md for report template.
Priority Handling
High Priority
Execute first. These typically address:
- Critical description issues
- Major writing style problems
- Missing structural elements
- Security-related concerns
Medium Priority
Execute after High. These typically address:
- Content organization improvements
- Additional examples
- Documentation enhancements
Low Priority
Execute last. These typically address:
- Minor clarifications
- Nice-to-have improvements
- Polish and refinement
Integration with Skill Quality Reviewer
This skill works seamlessly with
skill-quality-reviewer:
Current Skill (67/100 D+) ↓ [skill-quality-reviewer] Improvement Plan ↓ [skill-improver] Improved Skill (87/100 B+) ↓ [skill-quality-reviewer] Quality Report (validation)
Iterate until desired quality level reached.
Additional Resources
Reference Files
- Improvement plan file structure and formatreferences/plan-format.md
- Detailed merge algorithms and conflict resolutionreferences/merge-strategies.md
- Error handling strategiesreferences/error-handling.md
- Supported update types with examplesreferences/supported-updates.md
Example Files
- Sample improvement planexamples/improvement-plan-example.md
- Sample update reportexamples/update-report-example.md
Scripts
- Create backup of skill before updatesscripts/backup-skill.sh
- Verify skill integrity after updatesscripts/verify-update.sh
Best Practices
Before Applying Updates
- Review the improvement plan - Understand what will change
- Verify backup location - Ensure backups can be restored
- Check for manual changes - Note any uncommitted local modifications
- Estimate impact - Review expected quality improvement
During Update Execution
- Process in priority order - High → Medium → Low
- Verify after each file - Check updates were applied correctly
- Log all changes - Document what was modified
- Handle conflicts gracefully - Flag for review if needed
After Applying Updates
- Review the update report - Confirm all changes were intended
- Test the skill - Verify it still works correctly
- Compare scores - Check quality improvement matches expectations
- Keep backup - Retain backup until confident in changes
Usage Examples
Example 1: Apply improvements to local skill
User: "Apply improvements from improvement-plan-git-workflow.md" [Claude executes the workflow:] 1. Reads improvement-plan-git-workflow.md 2. Parses all improvement items 3. Groups changes by file 4. Detects and resolves conflicts 5. Sorts by priority 6. Backs up git-workflow skill 7. Executes updates 8. Verifies results 9. Generates update-report-git-workflow-timestamp.md
Example 2: Update skill from quality review
User: "Update my api-helper skill based on quality report" [Claude:] 1. Locates improvement-plan-api-helper.md 2. Applies all recommended changes 3. Verifies skill structure 4. Reports quality improvement: 72/100 → 91/100