Quality Checker Skill

Purpose

Single responsibility: Validate Claude skill packages for quality, completeness, and standards compliance before upload. (BP-4)

Grounding Checkpoint (Archetype 1 Mitigation)

Before executing, VERIFY:

• Skill directory exists
• SKILL.md is present
• Quality criteria are defined
• Validation scope is clear (quick/full/custom)

DO NOT validate without defining quality criteria.

Uncertainty Escalation (Archetype 2 Mitigation)

ASK USER instead of guessing when:

• Quality threshold unclear (strict vs lenient)
• Custom validation rules needed
• Failures found - block or warn?
• Edge cases in validation logic

NEVER auto-pass quality checks without proper validation.

Context Scope (Archetype 3 Mitigation)

Context Type	Included	Excluded
RELEVANT	Skill directory, quality criteria	Other skills
PERIPHERAL	Quality examples for comparison	Source documentation
DISTRACTOR	Build process	Enhancement history

Quality Dimensions

Dimension	Weight	Checks
Structure	25%	Required files, directory layout
Content	35%	SKILL.md completeness, references
Code Examples	20%	Presence, syntax, relevance
Documentation	20%	Clarity, navigation, completeness

Workflow Steps

Step 1: Structure Validation (Grounding)

# Required files
SKILL_DIR="output/<skill-name>"

# Check SKILL.md
test -f "$SKILL_DIR/SKILL.md" && echo "✅ SKILL.md present" || echo "❌ SKILL.md missing"

# Check references directory
test -d "$SKILL_DIR/references" && echo "✅ references/ present" || echo "❌ references/ missing"

# Check at least one reference file
ls "$SKILL_DIR/references/"*.md >/dev/null 2>&1 && \
  echo "✅ Reference files present" || echo "❌ No reference files"

# Check for index
test -f "$SKILL_DIR/references/index.md" && \
  echo "✅ Index present" || echo "⚠️ No index.md (recommended)"

Step 2: SKILL.md Content Validation

SKILL_MD="output/<skill-name>/SKILL.md"

# Required sections
echo "=== Section Check ==="
grep -q "^# " "$SKILL_MD" && echo "✅ Title present" || echo "❌ Missing title"
grep -q "^## Description\|^## Purpose" "$SKILL_MD" && echo "✅ Description present" || echo "❌ Missing description"

# Recommended sections
grep -q "^## Quick Reference\|^## Overview" "$SKILL_MD" && echo "✅ Quick reference" || echo "⚠️ No quick reference"
grep -q "^## Code Examples\|^## Examples" "$SKILL_MD" && echo "✅ Examples section" || echo "⚠️ No examples section"
grep -q "^## Navigation\|^## Contents" "$SKILL_MD" && echo "✅ Navigation" || echo "⚠️ No navigation"

# Content quality
echo ""
echo "=== Content Metrics ==="
echo "Lines: $(wc -l < "$SKILL_MD")"
echo "Code blocks: $(grep -c '```' "$SKILL_MD")"
echo "Sections: $(grep -c '^## ' "$SKILL_MD")"
echo "Links: $(grep -oE '\[.*\]\(.*\)' "$SKILL_MD" | wc -l)"

Step 3: Code Example Validation

SKILL_MD="output/<skill-name>/SKILL.md"

# Extract code blocks
echo "=== Code Examples ==="
example_count=$(grep -c '```' "$SKILL_MD")
echo "Total code blocks: $((example_count / 2))"

# Check for language tags
tagged=$(grep -c '```[a-z]' "$SKILL_MD")
echo "Language-tagged blocks: $tagged"

# Check code isn't just placeholders
placeholder_count=$(grep -E '```\n(# placeholder|// TODO|pass)\n```' "$SKILL_MD" | wc -l)
echo "Placeholder blocks: $placeholder_count"

# Minimum requirement: 3 real code examples
real_examples=$((example_count / 2 - placeholder_count))
if [ "$real_examples" -ge 3 ]; then
  echo "✅ Sufficient code examples ($real_examples)"
else
  echo "⚠️ Few code examples ($real_examples, recommend 3+)"
fi

Step 4: Reference Quality Validation

REF_DIR="output/<skill-name>/references"

echo "=== Reference Files ==="
for file in "$REF_DIR"/*.md; do
  if [ -f "$file" ]; then
    lines=$(wc -l < "$file")
    name=$(basename "$file")
    if [ "$lines" -lt 10 ]; then
      echo "⚠️ $name: $lines lines (sparse)"
    else
      echo "✅ $name: $lines lines"
    fi
  fi
done

# Total reference content
total_lines=$(cat "$REF_DIR"/*.md 2>/dev/null | wc -l)
echo ""
echo "Total reference content: $total_lines lines"

Step 5: Generate Quality Report

# Quality Report: <skill-name>

## Summary
- Overall Score: XX/100
- Status: PASS/WARN/FAIL

## Structure (25/25)
- [x] SKILL.md present
- [x] references/ directory
- [x] Reference files present
- [ ] Optional: scripts/, assets/

## Content (30/35)
- [x] Title present
- [x] Description clear
- [x] Quick reference
- [ ] FAQ section (missing)

## Code Examples (15/20)
- [x] 5 code examples
- [x] Language tags
- [ ] Example diversity (all Python)

## Documentation (18/20)
- [x] Navigation table
- [x] Links work
- [ ] Version info missing

## Recommendations
1. Add FAQ section based on common questions
2. Include examples in other languages
3. Add version/last updated info

Recovery Protocol (Archetype 4 Mitigation)

On error:

1. PAUSE - Complete partial validation
2. DIAGNOSE - Check error type:

   • File not found

     → Check path

   • Parse error

     → Check file format

   • Script error

     → Simplify validation
3. ADAPT - Adjust validation scope
4. RETRY - With corrected parameters (max 3 attempts)
5. ESCALATE - Report partial results

Checkpoint Support

State saved to:

.aiwg/working/checkpoints/quality-checker/

checkpoints/quality-checker/
├── structure_results.json
├── content_results.json
├── code_results.json
├── docs_results.json
└── final_report.md

Quality Thresholds

Level	Score	Action
PASS	80-100	Ready for packaging
WARN	60-79	Review recommendations
FAIL	<60	Address issues before packaging

Configuration Options

{
  "skill_dir": "output/myskill/",
  "validation_level": "full",
  "thresholds": {
    "pass": 80,
    "warn": 60
  },
  "requirements": {
    "min_skill_md_lines": 100,
    "min_code_examples": 3,
    "min_reference_files": 2,
    "require_navigation": true,
    "require_faq": false
  },
  "output": {
    "report_format": "markdown",
    "save_report": true
  }
}

Validation Levels

Level	Checks	Time
quick	Structure only	<5s
standard	Structure + content	<30s
full	All dimensions	<2m
strict	Full + extra rules	<5m

Custom Validation Rules

Add custom rules via configuration:

{
  "custom_rules": [
    {
      "name": "api_coverage",
      "type": "grep",
      "pattern": "^### .*\\(\\)",
      "file": "references/api.md",
      "min_matches": 10,
      "message": "API reference should document at least 10 functions"
    }
  ]
}

Troubleshooting

Issue	Diagnosis	Solution
False positives	Rules too strict	Adjust thresholds
Missed issues	Rules too lenient	Use strict mode
Slow validation	Full mode on large skill	Use quick mode first
Parse errors	Malformed markdown	Fix source files

Integration with Workflow

doc-scraper → skill-builder → skill-enhancer → quality-checker → skill-packager
                                                     ↓
                                              [If FAIL: fix issues]
                                                     ↓
                                              [If WARN: review]
                                                     ↓
                                              [If PASS: package]

References

• Claude Skills Quality Guidelines: https://docs.anthropic.com/skills
• AIWG Quality Standards:

  agentic/code/addons/writing-quality/

• REF-001: Production-Grade Agentic Workflows (BP-4, BP-9)
• REF-002: LLM Failure Modes (Archetype 1 grounding, Archetype 2 over-helpfulness)